Sudoku Elimination Range - Cells You Cannot Remove with Finned X-Wing, Coloring and Remote Pairs

/11 min read

Once you have found a pattern, widening the range of cells you clear is the quickest way to delete a cell's real answer. This article takes Finned X-Wing with its Sashimi form, Simple Coloring and Remote Pairs, and on grids made for this article lines up the cells you may clear next to the cells that look clearable but are not, with the reason for each line.

Cells that look clearable but are not

After learning a technique, it is easy to clear a slightly wider range of cells than the logic allows. Finned X-Wing, Simple Coloring and Remote Pairs are three techniques where the mistake comes after the pattern is found, when you decide which cells to clear. Removing a candidate from a cell outside the range can delete that cell's real answer, and the puzzle then has no solution. Here is the conclusion first. With a Finned X-Wing, you may clear only cells inside the fin's box that lie on the line through the corner in that box running in the direction the X-Wing clears (a column if the X-Wing is built on rows, a row if it is built on columns), and outside the two rows (or columns) the X-Wing is built on. With Simple Coloring, the only single cells you may clear are those that see cells of both colors; a cell that sees only one color stays. With Remote Pairs, you may clear only cells that see two chain cells an odd number of links apart. This article uses three grids made for it to set the clearable cells beside the cells that are tempting but must stay. How to spot each pattern and the full steps are left to the X-Wing and Coloring articles.

What a Finned X-Wing clears

The grid below is a position from a puzzle made for this article, advanced using only single-candidate cells and the only place a digit can go, until no more progress was possible. In this position, naked pairs, hidden pairs, pointing pairs and box/line reduction remove nothing at all. r stands for row and c for column, so r4c5 is the cell in row 4, column 5. Look at the digit 5. In row 1, a 5 can go only in r1c5 and r1c8. In row 6, the 5 has three cells: r6c4, r6c5 and r6c8. Without r6c4, rows 1 and 6 would form an X-Wing on columns 5 and 8. The extra r6c4 is the fin, and it sits in box 5 (the center box) with the corner r6c5. You may clear a cell only if it is inside box 5, in column 5 with the corner r6c5, and outside the X-Wing rows 1 and 6. Box 5 and column 5 overlap in r4c5, r5c5 and r6c5. r5c5 is already filled with 3, and r6c5 is a corner. That leaves only the 5 in r4c5 to remove.

A Finned X-Wing on 5, and r4c5 where the 5 can be cleared
1
2
6
4
7
3
8
5
9
3
7
3
6
3
8
4
5
4
7
3
8
1
2
1
8
4
3
3
5
6
4
4
6
8
1
5
3
9
1
3
4
  • The four corners of the X-Wing
  • Fin (r6c4)
  • Cell where the 5 can be cleared (r4c5)
  • In a corner column but outside box 5 (stays)
  • In box 5 but outside column 5 (stays)

Candidates for 5: row 1 has r1c5 / r1c8, row 6 has r6c4 / r6c5 / r6c8, column 5 has r1c5 / r3c5 / r4c5 / r6c5 / r9c5, column 8 has r1c8 / r3c8 / r6c8, and box 5 has r4c4 / r4c5 / r4c6 / r6c4 / r6c5.

Why cells outside the fin's box stay

The reason is easiest to read by splitting on whether the fin holds the 5. If the fin r6c4 is 5, no other cell in box 5 can be 5. If the fin is not 5, the 5 in row 6 goes in r6c5 or r6c8, and rows 1 and 6 become a real X-Wing. Then no other cell in columns 5 and 8 outside those two rows can be 5. The cells that cannot be 5 in both cases are the ones outside rows 1 and 6, inside box 5, and in column 5 or column 8. Column 8 does not pass through box 5, so only r4c5 in column 5 remains. SudokuWiki, a site that explains solving techniques one by one, also says that when the pattern becomes an X-Wing once the fin is ignored, the eliminations you keep are those in cells sharing a unit with every fin cell. r3c5 and r9c5 in column 5, and r3c8 in column 8, have no support when the fin is 5, so they stay. In this grid's answer, the fin r6c4 is 5 and the 5 in column 8 is r3c8. Clearing 5 from column 8 as if this were a plain X-Wing deletes the answer of r3c8. r4c4 and r4c6 in box 5 also stay, because they are not in column 5. If the fin is not 5 and r6c8 is 5, the 5 of box 5 can still be in one of those two cells.

The 5s in the first grid and whether the 5 can be cleared
CellPosition relative to the rangeCan the 5 be cleared?Answer in this grid
r4c5In box 5 and in column 5Yes6
r3c5In column 5, outside box 5No8
r9c5In column 5, outside box 5No7
r3c8In column 8 (which misses box 5)No5
r4c4In box 5, outside column 5No1
r4c6In box 5, outside column 5No9

Removing the 5 from r3c8, whose answer is 5, leaves the puzzle unsolvable. Even where the answer is not 5, keep the candidate until logic rules it out.

A Sashimi form keeps the same range

Sometimes the X-Wing corner in the fin's box has no candidate at all. SudokuWiki calls this form Sashimi and allows the X-Wing to be missing that corner in the finned box. The range is the same as for an ordinary Finned X-Wing: cells inside the fin's box that lie on the line through the missing corner running in the direction the X-Wing clears (a column if built on rows, a row if built on columns), and outside the two rows (or columns) the X-Wing is built on. The grid below comes from another puzzle made for this article, advanced the same way, and the digit is 2. In row 5, a 2 can go only in r5c6 and r5c8. In row 8, the 2 sits in r8c5 and r8c8. The cell that would be the corner, r8c6, is filled with 9 and has no candidate 2. r8c5 is the fin, in box 8 (the bottom center box) with the missing corner r8c6. The cell you may clear is r7c6, inside box 8 and in column 6; r9c6 in the same column is filled with 6. If the fin is 2, no other cell in box 8 can be 2. If the fin is not 2, the 2 in row 8 goes in r8c8, r5c8 in column 8 loses its 2, and the 2 in row 5 goes in r5c6. Either way, r7c6 cannot be 2. r4c6, in column 6 but outside box 8, stays. In this grid's answer, r4c6 is 2, so clearing it would delete the answer. r7c4 in box 8 stays as well, because it is not in column 6.

A Sashimi on 2, and r7c6 where the 2 can be cleared
1
2
4
9
5
3
7
5
3
4
7
1
9
9
7
1
3
4
5
6
5
9
7
3
4
3
4
1
9
6
7
5
7
2
8
3
5
4
9
6
1
9
3
4
5
7
6
4
7
6
5
9
1
3
1
5
7
3
6
9
4
  • The three remaining X-Wing corners
  • Fin (r8c5)
  • Cell where the 2 can be cleared (r7c6)
  • In the missing corner's column but outside box 8 (this technique cannot clear it)
  • In box 8 but outside column 6 (this technique cannot clear it)

Candidates for 2: row 5 has r5c6 / r5c8, row 8 has r8c5 / r8c8, column 6 has r4c6 / r5c6 / r7c6, column 8 has r5c8 / r8c8, and box 8 has r7c4 / r7c6 / r8c5. The missing corner r8c6 is filled with 9. The cells this technique cannot clear are outside the Sashimi range only, and applying the Coloring of a later section to the digit 2 also removes the 2 from r7c4.

When Coloring lets you clear a cell

The two ways Coloring clears candidates, cross elimination and the same-color contradiction (Color Trap and Color Wrap in the solver HoDoKu), are covered in the Coloring article. A cell that sees cells of only one color stays, however many of them it sees. If that color is the true one the candidate would be removed, but if the other color is true there is no reason to remove it. Take the digit 9 in the same position as the first grid. In column 6, the 9 is only in r4c6 and r7c6; in box 8, only in r7c6 and r8c5; in row 8, only in r8c5 and r8c9. Paint r4c6 and r8c5 as color A, and r7c6 and r8c9 as color B. r4c9 sees r4c6 (color A) along row 4 and r8c9 (color B) along column 9, so its 9 can be cleared. r7c9 sees r7c6 along row 7 and r8c9 along column 9, but both are color B, so it stays. In this grid's answer, color A holds the 9s and r7c9 is 9. SudokuWiki also lists a rule that removes a whole color when every candidate of the digit in some unit outside the network sees that same color. That rule removes the color because the unit would be left with no place for the digit; it does not mean a cell may be cleared just because it sees one color.

The colors of 9 in the first grid, and which cells can be cleared
CellColored cells it seesCan the 9 be cleared?Answer in this grid
r4c9r4c6 in color A and r8c9 in color BYes5
r7c9Only r7c6 and r8c9 in color BNo9
r4c5Only r4c6 and r8c5 in color ANo6

Color A is r4c6 / r8c5 and color B is r7c6 / r8c9. The 9 is also a candidate in r4c5 {1,2,5,6,9} / r4c9 {5,6,7,9} / r7c9 {1,7,9}.

Remote Pairs depend on odd or even links

A Remote Pair is a chain of cells that all hold the same two candidates, where each cell sees the next. HoDoKu describes it as the simplest chaining technique and requires the chain to be at least four cells long. Along the chain, if one cell is 2 the next is 7, so the values alternate. Two cells an odd number of links apart therefore hold different digits, and two cells an even number apart hold the same digit. You may clear a cell only if it sees two chain cells an odd number of links apart, and from that cell you may remove both digits. The grid below comes from a third puzzle made for this article, advanced the same way, and seven cells with candidates {2,7} form the chain. Take four of them: r5c8, r1c8, r1c4 and r2c5. r5c8 and r1c8 see each other along column 8, r1c8 and r1c4 along row 1, and r1c4 and r2c5 within box 2. From r5c8 to r2c5 there are three links, an odd number, so the two cells hold different digits. r5c5 sees r5c8 along row 5 and r2c5 along column 5, so both 2 and 7 can be cleared. r5c5 has candidates {1,2}, so removing the 2 leaves it as 1.

A {2,7} chain, and r5c5 where the 2 can be cleared
5
6
8
4
9
1
3
1
9
3
8
5
6
4
3
4
6
5
1
8
9
9
8
5
6
7
4
3
6
4
3
8
5
9
1
2
7
4
9
3
6
5
8
8
7
6
9
3
4
2
1
5
3
9
1
5
8
2
7
4
6
4
5
2
6
3
8
9
  • Same-value side A (r1c4 / r2c1 / r3c9 / r5c8)
  • Same-value side B (r1c8 / r2c5 / r3c1)
  • Cell where the 2 can be cleared (r5c5)
  • Sees two cells on the same side only (this technique cannot clear it)

Candidates of the empty cells: r1c4 {2,7} / r1c8 {2,7} / r2c1 {2,7} / r2c5 {2,7} / r3c1 {2,7} / r3c9 {2,7} / r4c4 {1,2} / r4c9 {1,2} / r5c5 {1,2} / r5c8 {2,7} / r5c9 {1,2,7} / r9c4 {1,7} / r9c5 {1,7}.

Two cells an even number apart do not count

In the same grid, r5c9 sees r5c8 along row 5 and r3c9 along column 9. Both are cells of the {2,7} chain, so it is tempting to remove 2 and 7 as with r5c5. But from r5c8 to r3c9 there are two links through r1c8, an even number. Two cells an even number of links apart hold the same digit. If both are 7, r5c9 can still be 2, and if both are 2, it can still be 7. So neither 2 nor 7 can be cleared from r5c9. SudokuWiki also states that two cells an even distance apart must hold the same number, which makes them useless for deciding the fate of a cell that sees them. In this grid's answer, r5c8 and r3c9 are 7 and r5c9 is 2. Removing the 2 deletes the answer of r5c9. Count the links along the shortest route through the chain. This chain contains a six-cell loop, but because the loop has an even number of cells, the count is odd or even the same way whichever direction you go.

Cells that see the {2,7} chain, and whether they can be cleared
CellChain cells it sees and links between themCan 2 and 7 be cleared?Answer in this grid
r5c5r5c8 and r2c5 (3 links, odd)Yes, both 2 and 71
r5c9r5c8 and r3c9 (2 links, even)Not by this technique2
r4c9r3c9 and r5c8 (2 links, even)Not by this technique1
r4c4Only r1c4Not by this technique2

Count the links between the two cells it sees along the shortest route through the chain. The cells this technique cannot clear are outside the Remote Pair range only, and applying Coloring to the digit 2 gives a same-color contradiction that also removes the 2 from r4c9 and the 7 from r5c9.

Common mistakes and how to spot them

The first mistake is clearing the whole X-Wing range after finding a fin. With a fin, the range shrinks to cells inside the fin's box on the line through the corner in the direction the X-Wing clears (a column if built on rows, a row if built on columns), outside the two rows (or columns) of the X-Wing. Before clearing, check that the cell sees every fin cell. The second is clearing any cell in the fin's box whether or not it lies on the line through the corner in the clearing direction. Cells off the line through the corner in the clearing direction (column 5 in the first grid), like r4c4 and r4c6, have no support in the case where the X-Wing holds. The third is clearing a cell in Coloring because it sees two cells of the same color. If it sees only one color, it stays no matter how many such cells it sees. The fourth is combining the colors of two chains that are not connected. Separate chains say nothing about which of their colors is true, and the SudokuWiki author also replies that two chains cannot be used together. The fifth is clearing a cell in a Remote Pair because it sees two chain cells. Count the links and confirm that the number is odd before you clear. How to back up after you notice a contradiction is covered in the article on being stuck.

Related articles and terms

How to spot each pattern and the steps are in the X-Wing, Swordfish and Coloring articles, and since SudokuWiki treats Remote Pairs as fully covered by Simple Coloring, the pattern can be reread with the two-color idea from the Coloring article. HoDoKu also notes that one or two Simple Colors moves give the same result as a Remote Pair.