How to Solve Killer Sudoku - A Cage Combinations Chart and How to Read Cages
Killer Sudoku starts from two things: cages whose sum allows only one set of digits, and the fact that every row, column and box adds up to 45. This article gives a chart of the sums that fix a cage's digits for each cage size, a table of digits that must or cannot appear even when several sets are possible, and the steps for reading cells that poke into or stick out of a region with the rule of 45.
Where do you start a Killer Sudoku?
The first Killer Sudoku most people try stops them cold: the grid has almost no digits in it. All you are given are cages, groups of cells outlined with dotted lines, and the sum written in each cage's corner. The short answer is that there are two places to look first. One is a cage whose sum allows only one set of digits. The other is the rule of 45, which uses the fact that the digits in any row, column or box always add up to 45. Those two give you the first placements, and from there the ordinary Sudoku techniques take over. This article shows, in order, a chart of the sums that fix a cage's digits for each cage size and the steps for reading the cells left over by the rule of 45. Note that the puzzles you can play on this site follow the standard rules; Killer Sudoku is covered here as something to read about.
Cage rules and how they differ
Killer Sudoku rests on the same base as standard Sudoku: each row, column and box holds the digits 1 to 9 once each. The difference is that the grid is divided into cages, and the digits in each cage must add up to the sum in its corner. Most puzzles start with very few given digits, or none at all. One more rule matters a great deal: no digit may repeat within a cage. The row, column and box rules alone would still let an L-shaped cage that bends across two boxes hold the same digit twice. SudokuWiki, a site that explains solving strategies one by one, describes the no-repeat rule as a convention dating from the earliest Killer puzzles. The same page notes that some publishers do not follow it, so it is worth checking a puzzle's instructions before you begin. The charts in this article assume that digits never repeat within a cage.
Chart of sums with one combination
A cage's sum fixes its set of digits when the sum sits near either end of its possible range. A two-cell cage can total anything from 3 to 17, and 3 can only be 1 and 2, 4 only 1 and 3, 16 only 7 and 9, and 17 only 8 and 9. Three cells range from 6 to 24 and four cells from 10 to 30, and again the two sums at each end have a single combination. The chart below was built by counting every way to choose distinct digits from 1 to 9. Knowing the set does not tell you which cell gets which digit. A two-cell cage of 3 still leaves the order of 1 and 2 open. Even so, if both cells lie in the same row, 1 and 2 can be removed from the rest of that row, exactly as a naked pair works in standard Sudoku. On a grid with nothing filled in, looking for sums near the ends first is what lets you start writing candidates.
| Cage size | Sum | Digits in the cage |
|---|---|---|
| 2 cells | 3 | 1 / 2 |
| 2 cells | 4 | 1 / 3 |
| 2 cells | 16 | 7 / 9 |
| 2 cells | 17 | 8 / 9 |
| 3 cells | 6 | 1 / 2 / 3 |
| 3 cells | 7 | 1 / 2 / 4 |
| 3 cells | 23 | 6 / 8 / 9 |
| 3 cells | 24 | 7 / 8 / 9 |
| 4 cells | 10 | 1 / 2 / 3 / 4 |
| 4 cells | 11 | 1 / 2 / 3 / 5 |
| 4 cells | 29 | 5 / 7 / 8 / 9 |
| 4 cells | 30 | 6 / 7 / 8 / 9 |
Built by counting every set of distinct digits from 1 to 9. For five-cell cages, the sums 15, 16, 34 and 35 each have a single combination.
Digits forced even with several sets
Even when a sum allows more than one set, a digit shared by every set is certain, and a digit that appears in none is ruled out. A three-cell cage of 8 can be 1 / 2 / 5 or 1 / 3 / 4, and 1 is in both. A three-cell cage of 22 is 5 / 8 / 9 or 6 / 7 / 9, so 9 must be there. A four-cell cage of 28 is 4 / 7 / 8 / 9 or 5 / 6 / 8 / 9, so it holds both 8 and 9. On the excluded side, a two-cell cage of 10 cannot contain 5, because putting 5 in one cell would force 5 into the other and repeat a digit inside the cage. For the same reason, a two-cell 12 cannot hold 6 and a two-cell 14 cannot hold 7. Once you know a digit must be in a cage, and the whole cage sits inside one box or one row, that digit can be removed from the other cells of that box or row. The table below lists typical sums for two- to four-cell cages that force a digit in or rule one out.
| Cage size | Sum | Number of sets | Must contain | Cannot contain |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 cells | 10 | 4 | none | 5 |
| 2 cells | 12 | 3 | none | 1 / 2 / 6 |
| 2 cells | 14 | 2 | none | 1 / 2 / 3 / 4 / 7 |
| 3 cells | 8 | 2 | 1 | 6 / 7 / 8 / 9 |
| 3 cells | 22 | 2 | 9 | 1 / 2 / 3 / 4 |
| 4 cells | 12 | 2 | 1 / 2 | 7 / 8 / 9 |
| 4 cells | 13 | 3 | 1 | 8 / 9 |
| 4 cells | 27 | 3 | 9 | 1 / 2 |
| 4 cells | 28 | 2 | 8 / 9 | 1 / 2 / 3 |
The number of sets counts the ways to choose distinct digits from 1 to 9. In a two-cell cage with an even sum, half of that sum is always ruled out.
Fixing one cell with the rule of 45
Every row, column and box holds 1 to 9 once each, so its digits always add up to 45. The rule of 45 puts that to work. Pick a box and add up the sums of the cages that lie entirely inside it. If exactly one cell of the box is left over, the difference from 45 is that cell's digit. Suppose a box contains three whole cages of 15, 12 and 14, and its last cell belongs to a cage that pokes in from outside. The three sums total 41, so the last cell is 45 minus 41, which is 4. If two cells are left over, the difference is their combined total, and treating the pair as a virtual cage lets you use the chart directly. A difference of 3 makes the two cells 1 and 2; a difference of 17 makes them 8 and 9. SudokuWiki points out that such virtual cages do not have to line up with the puzzle's own cage boundaries. Rows and columns work the same way: two of them together total 90, and three total 135.
Reading a cell that sticks out
The opposite case also occurs: one of the cages that cover a box reaches out of it by a single cell. Then you add up the sums of every cage that touches the box and subtract 45. The difference is the digit in the cell that sticks out. If the cages touching a box total 52 and only one cell lies outside, that cell is 7. English-language guides often call a cell poking into a region an innie and a cell sticking out an outie. When there is one innie and one outie, only the difference between their digits is known. As in the SudokuWiki example, when the cages lying inside the region plus the cage holding the outie total 5 more than the target, the innie is 5 less than the outie. In that shape you can narrow the candidates to pairs that differ by 5 (1 and 6, 2 and 7, 3 and 8, 4 and 9) and then compare them with other clues. The table below shows, for each region, the target total and what the leftover cells reveal.
| Region | Target total | Leftover cells | What you learn |
|---|---|---|---|
| One row, column or box | 45 | One innie | 45 minus the cage sums is that cell's digit |
| One row, column or box | 45 | One outie | The cage sums minus 45 is that cell's digit |
| One row, column or box | 45 | Two innies | Their combined total, which the chart can narrow |
| One row, column or box | 45 | One innie and one outie | The difference between the two digits |
| Two rows or columns | 90 | One innie or outie | The same subtraction as for one region |
| Three rows or columns | 135 | One innie or outie | The same subtraction as for one region |
Each extra unit adds 45 to the target. When leftover cells share no row, column or box, the same digit can appear twice among them.
Steps toward the first placement
Here are the tools so far, arranged as an order for opening a puzzle. First, any one-cell cage simply shows its digit as its sum. Next, scan the whole grid for cages whose sums sit at the ends of the chart, and note their sets of digits in the corners. Then go through the boxes one at a time, add up the cages lying wholly inside each, and look for a box with one or two cells left over. If no box works, try the same count on single rows and columns, and then on pairs of them. The wider the region, the longer the addition, so working from narrow regions outward also means fewer counting mistakes. At every stage, as soon as a digit is placed, apply it both to its row, column and box and to its cage, and update the noted sets before moving on to the next region.
Combining cages with standard techniques
After the first placements, alternate between cage combinations and standard Sudoku techniques. Every digit you place lowers the remaining total of its cage and narrows the possible sets. If a 9 goes into a three-cell cage of 15, the other two cells total 6 and must be 1 and 5 or 2 and 4. A pair of 3s is out, since it would repeat a digit in the cage. When a cage's set confines two digits to two cells of one row, those digits can be removed from the rest of the row, just as with a naked pair. It also works in reverse: when a standard technique removes a candidate, the cage's sets shrink too. In a two-cell cage of 10, removing 3 from one cell removes 7 from the other. While writing candidates, it helps to jot the possible sets for each cage small in its corner, so you notice the moment one of them disappears. As cells fill, the sets narrow quickly, and the endgame often feels close to standard Sudoku.
Common mistakes and how to spot them
Mistakes in Killer Sudoku tend to come from overlooked rules and miscounts. The first is forgetting that digits do not repeat within a cage. If you are tempted to put 5 and 5 into a two-cell cage of 10, that rule is the one to remember. The second is miscounting the cells of a region for the rule of 45. Confusing a cell that pokes in with one that sticks out flips the direction of the subtraction. To catch it, count the cells of every cage touching the region and list the cells outside it and the cells left inside it separately. The third is treating two leftover cells as an ordinary cage after combining two or more rows. If the two cells share no row, column or box, they can hold the same digit, so a total of 12 still allows 6 and 6. SudokuWiki likewise warns that outies are not bound by the no-repeat rule. The fourth is confusing a known set with a known order. Knowing that a two-cell cage of 17 holds 8 and 9 does not tell you which is which; that takes another clue. Other kinds of variant puzzles, and the naked pairs and pencil marks that cage sets build on, are covered in the related articles and glossary entries.